Thursday, January 30, 2014

Everyone does not Belong in Juvie

TOI [30-Jan] mentions a 17-year old boy who was sent to juvie because he got a 21-year old pregnant. Now, if he’s 17 and she’s 21, shouldn't she be sent to jail for seducing a minor? Crime is gender agnostic and when an adult sleeps with a minor, the adult is charged with rape—end of story.

What’s even stranger is the woman’s claim that this kid had promised to marry her. Really? He’s a minor, with no steady income and you sleep with him for a year. You get pregnant and keep the child, fine, but then you charge him with exploiting you. How can we hold a 17-year old child responsible for knowing who he wants to marry?

How can we expect anyone in this world to get married before they are 30? Say it, I’m being ridiculous, right? No, wait a minute, this newspaper article is. Life experience will tell you that a marriage is a marathon and you can’t run a marathon without training for a few months/years. Dating is the training.

Dating, living-in, one night stands, relationships—all these are essential training tools for people to discover who they are, deal with their insecurities, make their mistakes and realize what they expect from a partner. Men, women or transgenders—each one needs to outgrow this learning curve before entering into a marriage.

But in our culture, we insist that people turn every romantic-sexual interaction into a marriage, even if they have no training. And then despite best efforts, the shin splinters, the ankle twists, the ligament tears and extramarital one night stands and dating become the norm. As for being misled by a boy’s promise of marriage, women need to realize that when they sleep with someone, they are taking a risk and a man has a right to change his mind just as a woman does.

Okay yell at me everyone: what will happen to the girl, what about the girl’s reputation, if they don’t get married, the boy will have all the fun and leave her, blah blah blah. Hmm… my responses...

First, by not allowing our daughters to earn emotional maturity, we’re setting them up to become immature wives and mothers. Second, just because a man marries you, does it guarantee that he’s stopped sleeping with someone else? Third, you can catch STDs from a marriage as much as you can from a one night stand. Fourth, often boys don’t promise to marry but women jump down their throats so unless a boy/man clearly proposes to you, it is not a promise. Fifth, sometimes after a first sexual encounter a boy might discover he’s gay or a girl might realize that she’s lesbian. Both might not want to admit it but might want to break up. Should they still hold each other to the promise of marriage?


If a woman changes her mind, won’t we support her? Let us be equally courteous towards our young sons. Men and women are both horny and sexually curious and as long as both are adults and mutually agreeable, they do not need to be married to reach out to one another. If you read the article, you will realize that the girl was studying away from home; she was probably lonely and this boy was her only comfort. But now that hasn’t got what she wants—the boy is a criminal. Not fair. To the all women police station at Vallampudhur, I request you: arrest her for having sex with a minor, release the boy. Counsel him that he should not promise marriage unless he is 21 or get women pregnant. Teach both of them how to use protection. Let them jointly figure out how to raise their child. 

No comments:

Post a Comment